2026 Eagles Stay or Go: The Results

There were the usual favorites on both sides of the ball — as well as a few new faces — and a grizzled veteran that fans can’t seem to agree on.

Eagles fans want pending free agent linebacker Jaelan Phillips back next season, but they're split over veteran Brandon Graham, who came out of retirement last year.
Eagles fans want pending free agent linebacker Jaelan Phillips back next season, but they're split over veteran Brandon Graham, who came out of retirement last year.Yong Kim / Staff Photographer

The Eagles have long-since been eliminated from Super Bowl contention, after their wild-card round loss to the San Francisco 49ers. But the conversations around what went wrong with the Birds last year are ongoing, as the team continues to search for a new offensive coordinator and prepares for what’s sure to be a busy offseason.

We asked you, our readers, which Eagles you want to see stay or leave the team for next season. Here’s what we found — and how some of those results compared to what beat writer Jeff McLane expects the team to do …

Voted To Go
Voted To Stay

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%100%0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%100%

DeJean96.1%

Mitchell96.4%

Bennett26.9%

Blankenship82.8%

Brown57.5%

Carter II17.8%

Castro-Fields7.2%

Elliott23.2%

Epps64.8%

Jackson23.2%

McWilliams54.7%

Mukuba90.3%

Nickerson9.7%

Ringo28.5%

Sam17.8%

Carter95.5%

Davis96.1%

Graham40.6%

Hall64.7%

Ojomo94.9%

Okoronkwo20.3%

Robinson83.7%

Young84.1%

Baun95.8%

Campbell95.6%

Campbell37%

Dean72.1%

Hunt95.3%

Johnson18.9%

Mondon Jr.74.2%

Ojulari17.5%

Phillips81.4%

Smith Jr.91.5%

Trotter Jr.93.5%

Uche25.1%

VanSumeren28%

Jurgens91.2%

Kendall83.5%

Lampkin IV38.4%

Hinton73.6%

Dickerson93.6%

Hughlett21.2%

Johnson88%

Johnson91.8%

Mailata95.9%

Pierce73.4%

Pryor27.2%

Steen80.7%

Toth79.6%

Williams84.3%

Hurts85.7%

Howell25.5%

McCord35.3%

McKee84.9%

Cooper84.2%

Brown62.3%

Covey81.1%

Dotson32.1%

Smith95.5%

Marshall9.6%

Watkins12.1%

Wilson67.9%

Barkley93.1%

Bigsby94.7%

Dillon12.6%

Shipley77.2%

Mann94.2%

Calcaterra36.8%

Goedert79.4%

Granson17.1%

Jenkins15.9%

Latu66.4%
  • The Eagles’ All-Pro cornerback duo, Quinyon Mitchell (96.4%) and Cooper DeJean (96.1%), graded out the best of any Birds players. But they weren’t alone. Jordan Davis (96.1%) tied DeJean after a breakout year.

  • The best defense

    It’s not just those two. Overall, 19 Eagles earned over 90% stay votes in this year’s poll, despite the early playoff exit — 12 of those players were on defense or special teams, including Zack Baun (95.8%), Jalyx Hunt (95.3%), and more.

  • On the offensive

    There were fewer on offense — seven in total — who received at least 90% stay, including four offensive linemen: Lane Johnson (91.8%), Jordan Mailata (95.9%), Landon Dickerson (93.6%), and Cam Jurgens (91.2%).

  • Quarterback Jalen Hurts (85.7%), however, was not one of them. That doesn’t mean he’s unpopular — he finished just a few percentage points shy of his Super Bowl MVP season (89.5%), and is not going anywhere.

  • Brown takes a hit

    That’s nothing compared to the dip A.J. Brown (62.3%) saw. The wide receiver came in at 88.8% stay following last year’s Super Bowl run. But after a season wrought with controversy, where Brown looked like he may have taken a step back, fans have soured a bit on Brown.

  • Tight ends on the move?

    Backup tight end Grant Calcaterra (36.8%) fell over 55 points from last season — down from 92.3% stay after 2024 — but fans still love Dallas Goedert (79.4%). However, Jeff McLane thinks both pending free agents will be wearing different colors next year.

  • Love ’em or hate ’em

    Overall, the results on the offensive side paint an interesting picture, with no one player landing in the middle 20%, between 40-60% stay. Fans know what they want.

  • Special requests

    That includes the team’s specialists. An overwhelming majority want punter Braden Mann (94.2%) back next season. The same can’t be said for veteran kicker Jake Elliott (23.2%), who saw the biggest year-over-year drop. McLane thinks the team will agree.

  • A difference of opinion

    Franchise legend Brandon Graham (40.6%) un-retired midway through the 2025 season, and he said after the season that he felt he still had more in the tank. He was one of the most polarizing players in the poll, with a slight majority voting for him to go.

  • The kids are all right

    Howie Roseman also had a good year, according to fans. The Eagles’ rookie class, headlined by Jihaad Campbell (95.6%) and Drew Mukuba (90.3%), graded out well after its first NFL season.

  • The new guys

    The Birds traded for Jaelan Phillips (81.4%) at the trade deadline. While the move didn’t ultimately lead the Eagles to the Super Bowl, the pending free agent quickly became a fan favorite. Running back Tank Bigsby (94.7%) graded even better — and higher than Barkley.

  • Check out the full results

    We’re done breaking it down for you. Let’s put the numbers directly at your fingertips — simply hover over or click on a player on the chart to see not only what percentage of stay votes they received, but also what McLane thinks will happen.

So what does the future hold for these players? The NFL’s new league year begins on March 11 — that’s when teams are permitted to execute trades and begin signing new players. Stay tuned.

Advertisement

Staff Contributors

  • Reporting: Gabriela Carroll
  • Design and Development: Jasen Lo
  • Editing: Sam Morris, Matt Mullin
  • Copy Editing: Tony Moss

Subscribe to The Philadelphia Inquirer

Our reporting is directly supported by reader subscriptions. If you want more journalism like this story, please subscribe today