My mother-in-law gifted me an ugly Eagles table runner.

Do I have to keep it?

Eagles table runner

You may have received some gifts recently that you do not love. It happens! I invited two Inquirer staffers to help figure out what to do when it does.

Have your own thoughts or other questions? Fill in the box at the end!

.inno-chat__body {
border-radius: 12px;
}

Evan Weiss
Deputy Features Editor

The question is… My mother-in-law gifted me an ugly Eagles table runner. Do I have to keep it?

Zoe Greenberg
Life & Culture Reporter

My immediate response is …. absolutely not.

Astrid Rodrigues
Senior Video Editor and Producer

I'd say be polite and say "thank you." And then do what you'd like with it.

Zoe Greenberg

I did ask my little sister, who is perhaps more polite than me, and she said put it out once and then never again.

Zoe Greenberg

Which, to me, seems like a burden.

Astrid Rodrigues

I don't think I'd put it out necessarily. I'd probably keep it stored away in a closet though.

Astrid Rodrigues

You never know when you might need an Eagles table runner?

Astrid Rodrigues

Maybe your kid one day will want an Eagles-themed birthday party.

Zoe Greenberg

To be honest, I would put it on the street immediately.

Evan Weiss

You're not afraid the mother-in-law would come over some Sunday and ask where it is?

Zoe Greenberg

I don't like bad gifts. I like to just give them away. But it probably would bite me in the butt.

Zoe Greenberg

Thankfully my mother-in-law has much better aesthetics than me and would never do this (shout out to Kera).

Evan Weiss

Astrid, would you also like to put in a disclosure about your mother-in-law?

Astrid Rodrigues

My MIL has good taste and she actually loves to give gifts for any occasion.

Zoe Greenberg

We can't be getting in trouble with our mother-in-laws here.

Astrid Rodrigues

My MIL is thankfully not the type of person to ask where something is though.

Astrid Rodrigues

That’s a bridge too far!

Zoe Greenberg

That would be insane.

Evan Weiss

Okay, if the question asker takes Zoe's advice and puts it on the street… what should they say if asked about it at a later date?

Astrid Rodrigues

Lie.

Zoe Greenberg

"It must be around here somewhere!"

Zoe Greenberg

And then make the gestures of searching.

Astrid Rodrigues

I'm half-kidding. Honestly, it depends on your relationship with your mother-in-law.

Astrid Rodrigues

I've told mine that I didn't really need the gift or have one already.

Zoe Greenberg

Oh. I would not do that.

Zoe Greenberg

But I feel like in this city someone might love to find an ugly Eagles table runner on the street, so it's like a beautiful gift you're passing along.

Evan Weiss

Your advice went from "I hate it, give it away" to "I'm being generous to my fair city."

Astrid Rodrigues

Both can be true.

Zoe Greenberg

You can get rid of the trash and feel virtuous simultaneously.

Zoe Greenberg

I mean, I'm not saying sell it at a markup on Facebook or something!

Evan Weiss

Fair!

Evan Weiss

Any last advice for the question asker?

Astrid Rodrigues

Whether you keep it or not, just say "thank you" and hope it doesn't come up again.

Zoe Greenberg

I wonder if there's a way to redirect the gift giver for future gifts, without having to say anything.

Astrid Rodrigues

Maybe say, "Oh I'm a Cowboys fan now!"

This conversation has been edited for length. Illustration by Steve Madden.

What other Very Philly Questions should we address?

Or any thoughts on the question at hand?

story continues after advertisement

Topics mentioned in this story