Phillies pitcher Orion Kerkering gets replaced by manager Rob Thomson in the eighth inning against the Atlanta Braves on Sunday, August 31, 2025 in Philadelphia.
Phillies pitcher Orion Kerkering gets replaced by manager Rob Thomson in the eighth inning against the Atlanta Braves on Sunday, August 31, 2025 in Philadelphia.Yong Kim / Staff Photographer

The Phillies are primed for big changes. Who needs to come back, and who needs to go?
Swipe and decide

For the second straight year, the Phillies won the National League East. And for the second straight year, the season came to an unceremonious end in the National League Division Series.

Dave Dombrowski tried to improve the roster at the margins last winter, signing pitchers Joe Ross and Jordan Romano and outfielder Max Kepler to one-year deals and trading for Jesús Luzardo. Neither Ross nor Romano threw a pitch for the Phillies after August.

The Phillies have around $170 million committed to eight players for 2026, plus nine arbitration-eligible players. But with several key members of the Phillies core set to hit free agency this year, they are primed for bigger changes. Will they go bigger and bolder this year?

“You’re always looking to get better, so we will be open-minded to that,” Dombrowski said at his year-end press conference on Thursday. “I think it's a little bit different in that there's some built-in situations for us that are going to have to be addressed. So where you go as a club is very much dictated on some of those moves that end up happening.”

As the Phillies consider their next move, you can have your say. Make your pick for each player by swiping the cards below — right for Stay or left for Go. Yes, just like Tinder. Finding it hard to decide? We'll also show you how other Inquirer readers have voted so far and what we think the team will do.

Advertisement

Pitchers

For the first time under manager Rob Thomson, the Phillies have a bona-fide closer to go with a top-end starting rotation. But some changes will be coming, with Ranger Suárez heading to free agency and the enduring Andrew Painter question. The Phillies also have to address their middle relief corps. Navigating the bridge from their starters to Jhoan Duran was a weakness during the playoffs.

#45

Zack

Wheeler

All-Star

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '27
Age
35

Inky Says Stay

March: Wheeler is expected back from thoracic outlet surgery in the first half of ’26. He had a 2.71 ERA before his diagnosis and was building another Cy Young-caliber year.

#55

Ranger

Suárez

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
30

Inky Says Go

March: Suárez is primed for a big payday, but with a crowded rotation and Andrew Painter on the way, it’s unlikely the Phillies will outbid other teams to keep him.

#27

Aaron

Nola

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '30
Age
32

Inky Says Stay

March: Hampered by injuries, Nola had a career-worst 6.01 ERA. But some better starts late in the year showed flashes of the old Nola, signaling a bounce back next season.

#50

Orion

Kerkering

Crowd says 
Contract
Pre-arbitration
Age
24

Inky Says Stay

March: If Kerkering regains confidence after that brutal finish, he’s worth keeping. Despite inconsistent execution, his 33.5% hard-hit rate at age 24 signals back-end potential.

#61

Cristopher

Sánchez

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '28
Age
28

Inky Says Stay

March: Sánchez stepped into the role of the Phillies’ ace in the absence of Zack Wheeler. He had a 2.50 ERA over 202 innings (22 quality starts) and his 8.0 bWAR led all pitchers.

#46

Jose

Alvarado

Crowd says 
Contract
Club option
Age
30

Inky Says Stay

March: If the Phillies are betting on first-half Alvarado — who had a 2.70 ERA and a 99 mph fastball before his PED suspension — it’s worth exercising their club option.

#58

Tanner

Banks

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
33

Inky Says Stay

March: Banks has developed into a reliable option against left-handed hitters, holding them to a .175 batting average this season.

#31

Walker

Buehler

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
31

Inky Says Go

March: Buehler had a 0.66 ERA in a tiny sample size (13⅔ innings) with the Phillies, but had major struggles with command all year. It would be risky to commit a rotation spot.

#59

Jhoan

Duran

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
27

Inky Says Stay

March: As the Phillies’ closer, Duran is the anchor of the bullpen. His 32 saves in 2025 were a career high.

#44

Jesús

Luzardo

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '26
Age
28

Inky Says Stay

March: Luzardo had some rough patches, but overall put together a strong season. His 183⅔ innings were a career high, and he finished second in the NL in strikeouts (216).

#54

Tim

Mayza

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
33

Inky Says Stay

March: Mayza pitched only 16⅔ innings in an injury-plagued season, but left-handed relievers with a 53.8% ground-ball rate can be hard to come by. He could be worth another shot.

#30

David

Robertson

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
40

Inky Says Go

March: Robertson had a 28.2% strikeout rate in 20 games. He has undeniable experience, but will be entering his age-41 season and the Phillies may prefer to build for the future.

#68

Jordan

Romano

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
32

Inky Says Go

March: Romano was a reclamation project that didn't pan out, and he ended the season on the injured list after struggling to an 8.23 ERA. A change of scenery will be best for all.

#25

Matt

Strahm

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '26
Age
33

Inky Says Stay

March: One of the leaders in the bullpen, Strahm can get lefties and righties out and is a solid setup man for Jhoan Duran. Strahm held opponents to a 4.3% barrel rate in 2025.

#57

Lou

Trivino

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
34

Inky Says Go

March: Trivino had a 1.343 WHIP across three teams. Though his numbers improved with the Phillies late in the year, they may prefer a more consistent middle relief option.

#99

Taijuan

Walker

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '26
Age
33

Inky Says Stay

March: Walker improved from his 2024 season as he bounced between the rotation and bullpen. There were still inconsistencies, but his fastball velocity increased to 92.1 mph.

All Pitchers rated!Jump to Catchers
Advertisement

Catchers

It isn’t usually the best idea to offer a multiyear contract to a catcher who is entering his age-35 season and coming off his worst offensive season in 10 years. But here’s the question: If not J.T. Realmuto, then who? The pitchers swear by Realmuto, and the Phillies are built on pitching. Maybe it isn’t such a difficult decision after all.

#10

J.T.

Realmuto

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
34

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: Signing a 35-year-old catcher to a multiyear contract usually isn't wise. But what's the alternative? As Cristopher Sánchez said, “We’re basically nothing without him."

#13

Rafael

Marchán

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
26

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: How do you evaluate a catcher who plays once a week? Say this: There's upside for a larger workload, although he remains the backup to J.T. Realmuto or a replacement.

#21

Garrett

Stubbs

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
32

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: After stepping back to triple A, he's out of minor league options. But if there's a way to keep him and Rafael Marchàn in the organization, catching depth is important.

All Catchers rated!Jump to Infielders
Advertisement

Infielders

The infield, to quote Dombrowski, is “pretty well solidified.” The Phillies prefer to keep Bryce Harper at first base, and Trea Turner quieted talk of a position change by making drastic improvements in his defense at shortstop. Bryson Stott will likely reprise his role at second base, with Edmundo Sosa providing an option against left-handed pitching. Get ready, then, for another round of Alec Bohm trade rumors. Third base is the one spot where change could be coming.

#7

Trea

Turner

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '33
Age
32

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: Behold the NL batting champ. Also, one of four Phillies players to bat .300 with at least 175 hits, 15 homers, and 30 steals in a season. He's squarely in his prime.

#3

Bryce

Harper

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '31
Age
33

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: Something seemed … off? … all season. Maybe it was his achy right wrist. He still finished 11th in OPS among NL hitters. Everything continues to revolve around No. 3.

#28

Alec

Bohm

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
29

Inky Says Go

Lauber: Get ready for another winter as a walking trade rumor. But after an injury-filled, league-average season with Bohm entering his walk year, the Phillies will be selling low.

#4

Otto

Kemp

Crowd says 
Contract
Pre-arbitration
Age
26

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: An undrafted Division II college player reaching the majors was one of the year's best Phillies stories. He'll have a chance to stick around as a right-handed bench bat.

#33

Edmundo

Sosa

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
29

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: A versatile fill-in all over the infield, he's also the lefty-mashing half of a potential second-base platoon with Bryson Stott. Either way, he brings energy and value.

#5

Bryson

Stott

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
28

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: He batted .310 with an .880 OPS after Aug. 1 by lowering his hands and moving closer to the plate, à la Kyle Schwarber. Maybe it unlocked peak Stott. At last.

All Infielders rated!Jump to Outfielders
Advertisement

Outfielders

It’s possible the Phillies could have an entirely new outfield. Nick Castellanos isn’t expected back. Harrison Bader and Kepler are free agents, with only Bader on the Phillies’ radar. Justin Crawford is on the way, but will he play center field or left? The answer could impact Brandon Marsh’s future. It’s the most unsettled area on the field … again. Oh, and there’s a $125-ish million question at DH, with free agent Kyle Schwarber.

#12

Kyle

Schwarber

All-Star

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
32

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: As long as the Phillies are spending $125 million or so, what about a solid outfield defender with a low strikeout rate? Cody Bellinger, anyone? Probably not over Schwarber.

#8

Nick

Castellanos

Crowd says 
Contract
Signed thru '26
Age
33

Inky Says Go

Lauber: In a hitting-depressed era, someone (Royals? Reds? Giants?) may take a one-year flier. How much of his $20 million salary must the Phillies eat? Regardless, he's gone.

#16

Brandon

Marsh

Crowd says 
Contract
Arbitration elig.
Age
27

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: Subtract April, and he was seventh among NL outfielders in OPS (.836). How's that for a trade pitch? Problem is, he's one of the Phillies' few outfield assets.

#2

Harrison

Bader

Crowd says 
Contract
Mutual option
Age
31

Inky Says Go

Lauber: If the Phillies are honest, he surpassed expectations after a deadline trade. Assuming he declines his $10 million option, bid him farewell and usher in Justin Crawford.

#17

Max

Kepler

Crowd says 
Contract
Free agent
Age
32

Inky Says Go

Lauber: A .791 OPS in August and September kept him from being a total bust. Overall, he underperformed a $10 million, one-year contract. He isn't the answer in left field.

#23

Johan

Rojas

Crowd says 
Contract
Pre-arbitration
Age
25

Inky Says Go

Lauber: You could do worse for late-inning defense and speed off the bench. But after Rojas was sent back to the minors in July, a change of scenery is probably best for everyone.

#37

Weston

Wilson

Crowd says 
Contract
Pre-arbitration
Age
31

Inky Says Stay

Lauber: He's out of minor league options, which could be a factor in a potential spring-training competition with Otto Kemp for a spot as a right-handed hitter off the bench.

All Outfielders rated!
Advertisement

Staff Contributors

  • Development: Sam Morris and Jasen Lo
  • Design: Sam Morris, Jasen Lo, and Luke Reasoner
  • Reporting: Scott Lauber and Lochlahn March
  • Editing: John Roberts and Jim Swan
  • Photo Editing: Danese Kenon
  • Photography: Staff Photographers, additional photography provided by Associated Press
Advertisement