How our readers’ votes Compare To the Michelin Guide

The Michelin Guide provided some shocks on Tuesday night. Here’s how accurate our readers were.

Last week, we asked our readers which restaurants deserved Michelin recognition. On Tuesday the long wait for Michelin Stars in Philly ended when the winners were revealed at a ceremony at the Kimmel Center. Here’s how close Inquirer readers were to the Michelin Guide’s recommendations…

Yes
No
Royal Sushi & Izakaya
64%
35%
Friday Saturday Sunday
62%
37%
Kalaya
58%
41%
Zahav
50%
49%
Vetri Cucina
46%
53%
Provenance
38%
62%
Vernick Food & Drink
36%
63%
Her Place
35%
65%
Mawn
33%
66%
My Loup
27%
72%
Honeysuckle
22%
77%
Andiario
21%
78%
Pietramala
21%
78%
Parc
21%
79%
Yes
No
Royal Sushi & Izakaya
64%
35%
Friday Saturday Sunday
62%
37%
Kalaya
58%
41%
Zahav
50%
49%
Vetri Cucina
46%
53%
Provenance
38%
62%
Vernick Food & Drink
36%
63%
Her Place
35%
65%
Mawn
33%
66%
My Loup
27%
72%
Honeysuckle
22%
77%
Andiario
21%
78%
Pietramala
21%
78%
Parc
21%
79%
Yes
No
Royal Sushi & Izakaya
64%
35%
Friday Saturday Sunday
62%
37%
Kalaya
58%
41%
Zahav
50%
49%
Vetri Cucina
46%
53%
Provenance
38%
62%
Vernick Food & Drink
36%
63%
Her Place
35%
65%
Mawn
33%
66%
My Loup
27%
72%
Honeysuckle
22%
77%
Andiario
21%
78%
Pietramala
21%
78%
Parc
21%
79%
Yes
No
Royal Sushi & Izakaya
64%
35%
Friday Saturday Sunday
62%
37%
Kalaya
58%
41%
Zahav
50%
49%
Vetri Cucina
46%
53%
Provenance
38%
62%
Vernick Food & Drink
36%
63%
Her Place
35%
65%
Mawn
33%
66%
My Loup
27%
72%
Honeysuckle
22%
77%
Andiario
21%
78%
Pietramala
21%
78%
Parc
21%
79%
Yes
No
Royal Sushi & Izakaya
64%
35%
Friday Saturday Sunday
62%
37%
Kalaya
58%
41%
Zahav
50%
49%
Vetri Cucina
46%
53%
Provenance
38%
62%
Vernick Food & Drink
36%
63%
Her Place
35%
65%
Mawn
33%
66%
My Loup
27%
72%
Honeysuckle
22%
77%
Andiario
21%
78%
Pietramala
21%
78%
Parc
21%
79%
  • Readers
    Michelin Guide

    Only one restaurant – Friday Saturday Sunday – received both a star from the Michelin Guide and a yes from a majority (62%) of our readers.

  • Readers
    Michelin Guide

    Two other restaurants were given a Michelin star but received majority no votes from our readers – Her Place and Provenance, with only 35% and 38% of readers voting yes.

  • story continues after advertisement
  • Readers
    Michelin Guide

    Royal Sushi & Izakaya clinched a 64% yes from our readers. While it was snubbed for a Star, it still secured a Bib Gourmand – a category for establishments with excellent, albeit not star-worthy, food for the price.

    More than half of our readers also voted yes for Kalaya and Zahav. Although they didn’t receive a star, they both earned a spot on the guide’s list of recommendations.

  • Readers
    Michelin Guide

    None of these restaurants received a Michelin star, which our readers agreed with.

    But stars aren’t the only way the guide gives restaurants their flowers. Vetri Cucina, Vernick Food & Drink, My Loup, Honeysuckle, and Pietramala all landed spots on the guide’s recommendations list.

    Pietramala also received a Green Star award for its commitment to sustainability.

Hungry for more Michelin coverage? Check out our recap of last night’s ceremony and the most vital 76 Philly-area restaurants of 2025.

story continues after advertisement

Staff Contributors

  • Design, development, and reporting: Charmaine Runes
  • Data: Charmaine Runes and Aileen Clarke
  • Editing: Sam Morris
  • Illustration: Steve Madden
  • Copy Editing: Brian Leighton