We asked you where South and Central Jersey start. The results are in.

After thousands of responses we can finally answer whether Central Jersey exists

Illustration of an NJ license plate
Illustration of an NJ license plateJulia Duarte / Staff Illustration, Courtesy of

In January, we asked you the question: Where does South Jersey end and the rest of New Jersey begin? We let readers divide up the state and after thousands of submissions, here’s what you said.

story continues after advertisement
  • Readers were asked to draw a line where they believed South Jersey starts. Here is every individual submission we received. As you can see, the lines are scattered across the state, but there is a focus on the center of the state.

  • In the end, the average divider marking South Jersey sat near Burlington, Trenton, and just south of Toms River.

  • There were many factors that influenced where people drew their line, from using towns and counties to highways and area codes as boundaries.

    I-195 was a popular point of division. “The dividing line in my mind is I-195, which goes from around Trenton east to the shore,” Will Dean from South Jersey wrote.

  • story continues after advertisement
  • Cultural factors also played a role. Eagles or Giants? Phillies or Mets? Flyers or Devils? Taylor ham or pork roll?

    According to an analysis of Twitter accounts and what teams they follow, the county divide between Eagles fans and Giants fans tracks very closely with where readers drew the line.

  • After readers answered where South Jersey starts, we asked the more controversial question: Does Central Jersey exist? An overwhelming 74% of readers said that it did.

    If a reader said yes, we challenged them again to draw the line between North and Central Jersey. Every line represents a submission.

    Rebecca Overholt, a reader who has lived in all regions of the state, said of Central Jersey: "You get NYC and Philly stations in both TV and radio. You can find Eagles fans, Giants fans, and Jets fans all on the same block, and the only reason they get along is the jerk who flies a Dallas flag.”

    Julie Lawson, another reader from South Jersey, weighed in, saying: “South and North Jersey are distinctly different. Central Jersey is amorphous and sort of exists where the two mix, sort of like the brackish water between fresh and saltwater.”

  • The average line was south of Hillsborough and New Brunswick.

    “Happy to see a majority think Central Jersey exists because it does. I'd argue that New Brunswick is the dividing line; its county name, MIDDLEsex, screams Central Jersey,” said Tim Quinn, a Central Jersey reader.

  • As you can see, we are far from reaching a consensus here.

Maybe the one point New Jerseyans can agree on is best said by reader Ryan Wall: “Regardless of whether or not people believe Central Jersey exists, one thing everyone in the Garden State can agree on is that it's the greatest place in the world to call home. Lest we forget: ‘We're from Jersey, baby, and you're not.’”

What should we settle next?

Staff Contributors

  • Design, development, data, and reporting: Garland Fordice
  • Editing: Sam Morris
  • Art Direction: Julia Duarte
  • Copy Editing: Brian Leighton

Topics mentioned in this story